User blog comment:Httyd big fan/Thirty-Fifth Dragon Fight Club Match: Night Fury vs. Light Fury/@comment-39371123-20190508055459

I do this kind of thing to the point where I have become a master as it, so here's what I say:

First, we need to have a look at the PLACE they're fighting. This can always effect the two dragons, but since they are pretty much teh same species, with many fans flying with the hypothesis that they ARE the same species, we can safely say that wherever they are, both will have virtually the same attributes, pros and cons. So let's begin.

I hope we're not assuming it's Toothless and the Light Fury: let's assume its just two random furies. We'd need to know their stage to be ecactly sure, but if we presume they're both BroadWing. that leaves a lot of breathing space for closer to home resrevationals. If we consider the unique characteristics of both dragons, we could argue that Night Fury's are not, as some sources state, 'OP'. The only Night Fury we have seen in action being Toothless, who has trained with Hiccup for extensive amounts of time. Therefore, we can safely say that, though an ordianry Night Fury's timings and stats would be good, they would be no where near as good as Toothless' specific stats. (May I just say, there exists a theory that in HTTYD 1, when Berk is being said to be 'attacked by Night FuryS- note the S- ' most fans fly on the theory that teh attacker has alwyas been Toothless, but other fans think that the Night Fury was actually, as the Berkians first tjoguht, several Night Furys, who were either all killed be vikings or fled into the forest when Toothless, their leader, was shot down. They then gave him up for the dead and left, flying on to teh hidden world or some other place of refuge in the archapelago. It's a nice tehory, but I persoanlly dont believe it.)

Now setting also is a huge factor. If it's at night the Night Fury has a distinct advantage since they camouflage, the Light Fury is left exposed although the Light Fury has an advantage of cloaking itself though we do not know how much energy that consumes and how long a Light Fury can remain cloaked.

It's difficult to tell which of these dragons would win because we haven't seen all of the abilities of the Light Fury and we have never witness a wild Night Fury fight. The closest we have come to seeing this is during the cage matches in "Stryke Out" but even that isn't a great example since Toothless had training previous to the fights.

It is important to know physical combat but mental combat is also important. Though these dragons have the same intellgence stat that does not necessarily mean they think the same battle stratergy.

I am going based off of what I've seen and personally I feel that the Night Fury would win. What I have witnessed in the series is the Night Fury uses it's abilities to outsmart it's opponants which I feel is a very big strength. Although having physical characteristics in battle does play a part having the mental strategy during in a battle gives you that edge.

But, to be honest, the Light Fury is often even smarter, and if her interactiosn with Toothless are anythign to go by, we can safely say that the Light Fury will win.

I think what we're really saying here isthat it depends on the dragon in particular.

This has probably 1 million spelling mistakes I only briefly edited it! But this is my view.