User blog comment:Annabeth and Percy/Second Dragon Fight Club Match!/@comment-26435499-20170220213803

I actually dislike how biased this poll is. Of course this match is one sided considering how so many people prefer Astrid over Heather. The OP wanted an honest answer on who would win in a fight, not who you like better. Imo, it's a tie as hinted to us numerous times in the show.

TBH, out of all the riders I dislike Astrid the most because of how unappreciative she is. Like c'mon the only person she listens to is Hiccup (and Heather, but she's technically not a permenant rider so I didn;t count her in). We can clearly see her lack of respect to the other riders, even to Fishlegs.

Heather is also a strong and likable female character but at least she has a better and more friendly personality. Astrid is downright...well, I wont say the word but I'm sure u get the point.