Talk:Astrid Hofferson/@comment-3263704-20190414120407/@comment-4141088-20190421230242

If we're only taking movies as canon and leaving the series out of it, even Valka's name being listed as "Valka Haddock" is a stretch, since their names are never given as anything but Stoick the Vast and Valka the nothing. Presumably, there were two other Hiccup Haddocks somewhere back along the line and he's named after them, and this is perfectly in keeping with a group of people who play very fast and loose with names.