User blog comment:Annabeth and Percy/Second Dragon Fight Club Match!/@comment-352641-20170218175531

I voted tie, but I think both of them have the potential to beat the other. Either way it'll be an EXTREMELY close fight. I'd personally give it a little more to Astrid as Astrid seems to have more combat experience, but it's not enough to be a definitive win/lose decider.

Still, it's close enough that it'd be 50/50 as to who would win, and probably heavily reliant on chance. Valhalla will have plenty of entertainment for a few weeks as they sort it out at least! :D